Property Description

A rare opportunity to own land in one of Fire Island’s most beloved communities. Fair Harbor offers a classic beach town feel with easy ocean and bay access, a tight-knit neighborhood vibe, and a strong summer rental market. This is two separate parcels being sold together as one. This property is on the east side of Fifth Avenue on the bay side.

Basic Details

Add On Video :

Property Type : Land

Listing Type : For Sale

Listing ID : 1003608

Price : $1,175,000

Make An Offer : $$

Lot Area : 0.13 Acre

Status : Active

Office Name : Kitty King

Agent Name : Michael Nardone

Agent Contact : mnardone042@gmail.com

Address Map

Country : US

State : NY

County : Suffolk County

City : Islip

Zipcode : 11706

Longitude : W74° 2' 26.8''

Latitude : N40° 46' 59.3''

Zoning : BAA

Neighborhood

Elementary School : Fifth Avenue School

Elementary School District : Bay Shore

High School : Bay Shore Senior High School

High School District : Bay Shore

Middle Or Junior School District : Bay Shore

Middle School : Bay Shore Middle School

Additional Information

Current Use : Vacant

On Market Date : 2026-05-23

Previous Price : 1400000

Financial

Tax Annual Amount : 4461

Listing Information

List Agent Mls Id : 217580

List Office Mls Id : KTKN01

Mls Status : Active

Modification Timestamp : 2026-07-20T15:54:36Z

Originating System Name : OneKey

Special Listing Conditions : None

Status Change Timestamp : 2026-05-23T15:06:32Z

Google Map

Land

5th Avenue, Islip, New York 11706

0.13 Acre

Visits : 0 in 154 days

$1,175,000

Listing ID #1003608

Make An Offer

Make Your Offer Here

Share on Facebook
Share on Twitter
Share on Pinterest

Agent info

Land

5th Avenue, Islip, New York 11706

Your VIP pass to the pros you actually need